Wednesday, October 12, 2011

Is Fish purer than meat in Hinduism...!?


In the way back from Beed to Sollapur Railway Station, Maharashtra (10th of Oct, 2011) for Banglore after my field work, our team  stopped our vehicle at a place where it is somewhat considered to be famous for fish hotels. And, where just within few steps there is a bigger temple also.

I am not confirm that the business inertia of the hotels are because of Fish availability or because of nearness to the temple, or it was in the junction of road-cross, or because of all these factors. I and some of other my team members got into an Islamic hotel as I am Islamic, in motive to get some lawful (halal, there is scientific reason why I take only halal)meats.

Unfortunately we came to know that meats are not available in all of the hotels there, which is an unusual for an Islamic hotel not to available meats. I asked why is that….? The answer was simple-This place is quite near to a temple so meat is not allowed here.  I was speechless with the reason.

I thought suddenly, are the fishes not moving animal like terrestrial birds and animals. Here lets compromise their unreasonability over plants if they think animal feels more pain than plant, which is not truth that science has already proved that plants also feels the same pain as that of animals, then do the fishes not feel pain as that of terrestrial animals.

Or, if it is the motive to arrest the consumption of animals, as same reason of the myth of considering cow as a part of god to worship, does the number of fishes not dwindling?, are the fishes not never endanger because they are in sea?, which is not a truth at all.

In the movie "Indians Untouchables" one saint mentioned that man becomes impure if he eat meat. What is the purity of a man. Why we are given with Canine teeth and stomach which can digest meat, which all these are not given in herbivores like Cow, Goat and so on...god has created us with all these equipment's which means we are allowed to take meat but it doesn't meant to eat all kinds of living creatures.

Hindu scripts has clearly mentioned about non-prohibition of eating meat. Such an unreasonability / misperception should be attack first to stop unreasonability which is rooted (its not the intention to let veg-people eat meat, but the unreasonability of people at mass which affect other sectors of living) in their religion.

I don't know why Shri Shri Shiv Shankar, a globally know in Hinduism for his "Art of Living" never speak anything about caste and Untouchability which is rooted in Hinduism. It doesn't mean that Muslims community do not have untouchability, it do have but it never practice inside a mosque.

Many Hindu Dalits converted to Islam to find some equality in the society, they do get equality but in some places of India it does happen to discriminate still, between Muslim higher caste and lower caste but never inside  mosque, it is found in Bihar so far I have seen. Here, the concern is for the majority community (Hindus) which is practicing untouchability at mass.

Such an unreasonability cannot be uprooted using coercion like Police rather need to attack their minds intellectually, through preaching by religious persons. Because Police itself is rooted with such unreasonability of untouchability.

Indians take religious persons as value as god, then why people will not consider the words of those religious persons. So, we need highly educated, contemporary and scientific temper minded religious persons to preach the unreasonability or the misperceptions of Hinduism.

Otherwise it will take, as per my exaggerated assumption, another century to let people internalize the our constitutional ideology (which many religious and highly educated person still  not accepting, like equality of one's value), or to bring Indians at the level of Europeans, Americans, Koreans or Japanese or likes. But I don't mean Europe and Western and Eastern developed nations do not have any kind of discrimination,  they also do have discrimination but not up to that level of Indians.



--
# Yasin Kh .
http://www.google.com/profiles/ansary.shent